Quick Take
Score: 8.5/10 | Aquagear sits between budget Brita and premium Clearly Filtered, offering NSF 42/53/401 certification with independent PFAS testing at a more accessible price. 150-gallon capacity provides excellent value.
Safety Analysis (40% weight) - Score: 8.8/10
Triple NSF Certification Plus PFAS Testing
NSF 42 for chlorine, NSF 53 for lead, NSF 401 for pharmaceuticals, plus independent lab testing showing 90%+ PFAS reduction. While not NSF P473 certified, the independent testing provides confidence.
89 Contaminants Removed
More comprehensive than Brita (30+) though less than Clearly Filtered (365+). Includes fluoride, chromium-6, and arsenic that many filters miss.
Made in USA
Manufactured in the USA with domestic quality control.
Efficacy Analysis (35% weight) - Score: 8.5/10
150-Gallon Capacity
Excellent filter life - better than Clearly Filtered (100 gallons) and ZeroWater (15-40 gallons).
Fluoride Reduction
One of few pitcher filters addressing fluoride - typically requires RO systems.
Retains Beneficial Minerals
Unlike ZeroWater, Aquagear keeps calcium and magnesium while removing contaminants.
Value Analysis (15% weight) - Score: 8.0/10
2-Pack Price: $54.99
Approximately $27.50 per filter. Annual cost: $65-80 depending on usage.
Cost Per Gallon: $0.18
Between Brita ($0.13) and Clearly Filtered ($0.45). Fair pricing for the certification level.
Lifetime Pitcher Guarantee
Aquagear guarantees their pitcher for life - exceptional confidence in their product.
The Bottom Line
Aquagear filters offer the sweet spot between budget and premium: NSF 42/53/401 certification, independent PFAS testing, and 150-gallon capacity at $0.18 per gallon. Excellent alternative to Clearly Filtered at lower cost.
