Quick Take
Score: 8.8/10 | The Aquasana AQ-5200 delivers the best balance of contaminant removal, convenience, and value for families ready to move beyond pitcher filters. I upgraded to this system when filling pitcher after pitcher became unsustainable for our family's water consumption.
What We Evaluated
This review uses R3's Water Filter Methodology v1.0.0.
Safety Analysis (40% weight) - Score: 9.0/10
Lead Removal: 99%
The Clario technology achieves NSF 53 certification with 99% lead reduction. This matches pitcher filters while delivering instant filtered water on demand.
PFAS Removal: 95%
NSF P473 certified for PFOA/PFOS removal at 95% - slightly below Clearly Filtered's 99.9% but still excellent for an under-sink system at this price point.
Emerging Contaminants: NSF 401 Certified
Pharmaceuticals, herbicides, and pesticides are covered. Removes 95%+ of prescription drug residues and glyphosate.
No Water Waste
Unlike reverse osmosis systems that waste 3-4 gallons per filtered gallon, the AQ-5200 produces zero waste water. Every gallon of municipal water becomes a gallon of filtered water.
Efficacy Analysis (30% weight) - Score: 9.0/10
Contaminant Count: 77
While lower than Clearly Filtered's 365, the AQ-5200 targets the most concerning contaminants: lead, PFAS, chlorine, chloramines, pharmaceuticals, and VOCs. Aquasana publishes independent test results from NSF-certified labs.
Filter Capacity: 500 Gallons (6 Months)
Each filter set handles 500 gallons - roughly 6 months for a family of 4. Compare this to pitcher filters lasting 1-3 months. Less frequent changes mean lower annual hassle and cost.
Flow Rate: 0.5 GPM
Half a gallon per minute through the dedicated faucet. Fast enough to fill a water bottle in seconds - no waiting like with pitcher filters.
Dedicated Faucet
The included brushed nickel faucet mounts next to your sink. Filtered water is always instant and ready.
Value Analysis (15% weight) - Score: 8.3/10
Upfront Cost: $129.99
More than a pitcher ($30-90) but far less than RO systems ($200-600). The dedicated faucet and 6-month filter life justify the investment.
Replacement Filter Cost: $59.99 per set
Two filters per year = approximately $120 annually. That's $0.12 per gallon - significantly cheaper than bottled water or premium pitcher filters.
5-Year Cost Comparison
| System | 5-Year Cost | Cost/Gallon |
|---|---|---|
| Aquasana AQ-5200 | $730 | $0.12 |
| Clearly Filtered Pitcher | $765 | $0.45 |
| Reverse Osmosis | $800+ | $0.15 |
The AQ-5200 wins on long-term value while delivering comparable filtration to more expensive options.
Usability (10% weight)
Installation: DIY Moderate
Requires basic tools (adjustable wrench, drill for faucet hole). Most homeowners can install in 45-60 minutes. Video tutorials available. Not recommended for renters unless your landlord approves.
Filter Changes: Easy
Twist-off cartridges every 6 months. No shutting off water supply - just twist, remove, replace. Takes 2 minutes.
Space Requirements
Fits under standard sinks. Two cylindrical filters plus housing require approximately 15"x12"x8" of cabinet space.
The Bottom Line
The Aquasana AQ-5200 is the best under-sink option for families wanting always-ready filtered water without the complexity and water waste of reverse osmosis. NSF P473 certification for PFAS removal, 6-month filter life, and instant access make it the logical upgrade from pitcher filters.






