Quick Take
The Brookstone Aqua-Jet earns an 8.4 overall as our runner-up. It matches or exceeds the HoMedics in massage capability with motorized shiatsu rollers, but the lack of collapsible design and higher price point keep it in second place for most families.
Overall Score: 8.4/10 - Excellent alternative
Why Runner-Up Instead of Winner?
The Brookstone offers deeper massage with motorized rollers, which some users will prefer. However, the HoMedics wins on practicality with its collapsible storage design. For families with ample storage space who prioritize intense massage, the Brookstone may actually be the better choice.
Performance Highlights
Motorized Rollers: The standout feature. Unlike fixed acupressure nodes, these rollers actively massage your arches and heels with adjustable intensity.
Heat Maintenance: Comparable to HoMedics Heat Boost - water stays warm throughout 45+ minute sessions.
Build Quality: Substantial construction that feels premium but weighs more.
The Bottom Line
Choose the Brookstone if motorized massage is your priority and storage space is not an issue. The higher price buys genuine premium features.
Final Score: 8.4/10 - Excellent for massage enthusiasts
