Quick Take
Score: 8.0/10 | Five Star has been a school supply staple for decades. While not the most sustainable option, the durability and value make it the practical choice for families who need reliability.
The Research
Five Star uses heavyweight paper that resists ink bleed-through - important for students who use pens. The poly cover withstands backpack abuse that destroys paper covers.
The spiral binding includes a wire guard to prevent snagging in backpacks and on clothing.
Real-World Testing
These notebooks survive a school year intact, which matters more than it sounds. Cheaper notebooks fall apart by March. The paper quality handles highlighters without excessive bleed.
The 200-sheet count provides genuine value for the price.
The Honest Assessment
What I Love: Durability is genuinely superior to budget alternatives. The wire guard prevents spiral snags. Paper handles various writing instruments well. Value per page is excellent.
What Could Be Better: No sustainability certifications (FSC, recycled content). Plastic poly cover isn't eco-friendly. Standard manufacturing without special safety considerations.
The Bottom Line
For families prioritizing durability and value over sustainability, Five Star delivers the reliable workhorse notebook that survives the school year.



