I started researching water-based nail polishes after a reader asked if there was anything safe enough to use during chemotherapy. That led me down a deep rabbit hole into polish formulations, and I found Honeybee Gardens WaterColors—the most radically different nail polish I've ever tested.
What Makes It Different
Most "clean" nail polishes are still solvent-based. They remove toxic trio ingredients (toluene, formaldehyde, DBP) but still rely on ethyl acetate or butyl acetate as the base. These create fumes and require acetone removal.
Honeybee Gardens took a completely different approach: their formula is 70% water. The result is genuinely odorless polish that peels off when you're done. No remover needed.
I tested this during my second trimester when I couldn't tolerate any chemical smells. I could apply it in my bedroom without opening windows. My daughter (age 4) sat next to me asking questions the whole time—something I'd never allow with conventional polish.
The Safety Profile
This is where Honeybee Gardens excels. Their formula avoids:
- All solvent fumes (no VOC exposure)
- Acetone exposure during removal
- The "toxic trio" (toluene, formaldehyde, DBP)
- Camphor, formaldehyde resin, parabens
- Xylene and ethyl tosylamide
The ingredients list reads more like a cosmetic cream than nail polish: water, acrylic copolymer, neem oil. I verified there are no CPSC recalls on this product.
This makes WaterColors appropriate for:
- Pregnancy (all trimesters)
- Breastfeeding
- Young children (I've used it on my 4-year-old)
- Chemotherapy patients (gentle enough for weakened nails)
- Anyone with asthma or chemical sensitivities
- Professional nail techs who want to reduce occupational exposure
How It Performs
Here's where I need to be honest: this won't perform like conventional polish.
I tested WaterColors for three weeks, applying different colors every 2-3 days. Here's what I found:
Dry time: 5-7 minutes to touch-dry, 15-20 minutes to fully set. Slightly slower than conventional polish but not dramatically different.
Finish: The dried polish has a chalky, matte appearance. It's not glossy like traditional polish. The color is softer and more muted. I tested their "Merlot" shade—it looked more like a dusty rose than a deep wine.
Wear time: 2-4 days before significant chipping. I got 3 days on my toes (less friction) but only 2 days on my hands. If you type a lot or wash dishes frequently, expect chips by day two.
Chip pattern: Interestingly, it doesn't chip the same way as regular polish. Instead of small edge chips, larger pieces tend to lift and peel. Once one nail starts going, I usually just peel the rest off.
Removal: This is genuinely impressive. When you're ready, you gently lift an edge and peel the polish off in one piece. It's oddly satisfying. My daughter thinks it's magic. No acetone, no scrubbing, no residue.
When I Use It
I keep WaterColors in rotation for specific situations:
Quick color for events: If I want polished nails for a weekend wedding but don't want the commitment, I apply this Friday night and peel it off Sunday evening.
Pregnancy-safe pedicures: During summer pregnancy, I used this for toes. The shorter wear time mattered less (sandal season = less friction), and I avoided all fume exposure.
Teaching my daughter: When she wants "grown-up nails" for dress-up, this is what I use. I can let her apply it herself without worrying about spills (it's water-based, so it washes right out of fabric).
Chemotherapy or medical situations: I recommended this to a friend going through chemo whose nails became brittle and sensitive. Traditional polish was too harsh; this worked.
The Bottom Line
Honeybee Gardens WaterColors is the safest nail polish I've found. If you're pregnant, have young kids who want polish, are going through medical treatment, or have chemical sensitivities, this is worth trying.
The performance limitations are real—you're getting 2-4 days of wear with a matte finish. But for many families, that's an acceptable trade-off for zero fume exposure and peel-off removal.
At $9.50 per bottle, it's affordable enough to try without major investment. I recommend starting with one neutral shade to test the formula before buying multiple colors.



