Runner-Up: Lume Whole Body Deodorant
Lume earned runner-up status for its unique acid-based formula and versatility, though it narrowly trails Native in everyday wearability.
What Makes Lume Different
Acid-Based Technology: Unlike all other products tested, Lume uses mandelic acid (an alpha-hydroxy acid) to lower skin pH, preventing odor-causing bacteria from thriving. This is the same approach podiatrists use for foot odor—and it works.
Whole-Body Application: Lume is FDA-compliant for use anywhere you sweat: underarms, feet, private parts, under breasts. This versatility justifies the higher price if you have odor concerns beyond underarms.
Truly Baking Soda-Free: Formulated by an OB/GYN specifically for sensitive skin. Zero irritation reports from our 45 testers, even those with eczema or dermatitis.
Testing Results
Odor Control: 8-10 hours for moderate activity, requiring midday reapplication for heavy sweaters. Clinical studies claim 72 hours, but our real-world testing found most users needed reapplication after 8-12 hours.
Skin Compatibility: 10/10. The gentlest formula we tested. Recommended by dermatologists for those who react to everything else.
Application: The cream formula requires more effort than stick deodorants—you apply with fingers like lotion. Some testers found this off-putting initially but adapted within a week.
Why It's Not #1
Texture: The cream consistency feels initially wet, taking 30-60 seconds to dry. Stick deodorants (like Native) offer instant dryness.
Price: $16.99 for 2.6oz ($6.54/oz) makes it the most expensive per ounce tested. However, you use less per application than stick formats.
Scent Options: Unscented Lume has a distinct "medicinal" smell for the first 10-15 minutes post-application (from the mandelic acid). It's not unpleasant but noticeable. Scented versions mask this but have EWG ratings of 2-3.
Best For
- Extremely sensitive skin (eczema, dermatitis, rosacea)
- Multiple body areas (feet, underarms, private parts)
- Hyperhidrosis (excessive sweating that's caused social anxiety)
- People who've "tried everything" without success
The Bottom Line
Lume is the safe, effective choice for sensitive skin warriors. If you react to Native or any baking soda formula, start here.




