Quick Take
Score: 7.6/10 | The ProOne Big+ delivers what Berkey promises but with actual third-party verification. While not NSF certified (the certification process differs for gravity systems), ProOne publishes lab results from EPA-accredited facilities testing to NSF protocols. This transparency, combined with USA-based support and reasonable pricing, makes it the gravity-fed system I recommend.
Safety Analysis (40% weight) - Score: 7.5/10
Third-Party Lab Testing
ProOne submits filters to EPA-accredited laboratories testing to NSF 42 and 53 protocols. Results are published on their website. This is not the same as NSF certification, but provides meaningful verification Berkey lacks.
Published Removal Rates
- Chlorine: 99.9%
- Lead: 99.9%
- Fluoride: 95%+ (with optional filter)
- PFAS: Claimed but limited verification
- Bacteria: 99.9999%
Transparent Company
USA-based company in Wyoming with responsive customer service. Willingly discusses testing methodology and limitations.
Efficacy Analysis (30% weight) - Score: 7.5/10
2.75-Gallon Capacity
Larger than Big Berkey (2.25 gallons), serving households of 4-6 comfortably.
Filter Life: 1,200+ Gallons
Each G2.0 filter element handles approximately 1,200 gallons. Pair of filters provides 2,400 gallons total, roughly 2-3 years for typical families.
Gravity-Fed Convenience
No plumbing, no electricity. Fill the top chamber, gravity does the rest. Portable for camping or emergency preparedness.
Optional Fluoride Filters
The PF-2 fluoride/arsenic reduction filters attach below the G2.0 elements. Essential for communities with fluoridated water if fluoride reduction is your goal.
Value Analysis (15% weight) - Score: 7.8/10
Upfront Cost: $350
Slightly less than Big Berkey ($415) with better transparency and USA support.
Long-Term Costs
Filter elements ($120/pair) lasting 2-3 years make ongoing costs reasonable.
The Bottom Line
The ProOne Big+ is the gravity-fed system for families wanting Berkey-style convenience with actual evidence of performance. Third-party lab testing, published results, and USA-based support provide accountability that Berkey lacks.





