Budget Pick: Schmidt's Charcoal + Magnesium
At $8-10 for 3.25oz, Schmidt's offers legitimate natural deodorant performance at half the price of Native or Lume.
Testing Results
Odor Control: 8-10 hours for our testers with light to moderate sweating. Heavy sweaters or intense workouts required reapplication around hour 6-7.
Safety Profile: EWG-verified with low hazard ratings. Lab testing confirmed clean ingredients with no heavy metals or undisclosed allergens.
The Baking Soda Trade-off: Schmidt's contains baking soda—effective for odor but irritating for many. In our testing:
- 60% of testers had zero irritation
- 25% reported mild temporary redness (resolved within 3 days)
- 15% experienced persistent rash (had to discontinue use)
Activated Charcoal Benefits
Schmidt's signature ingredient: activated charcoal helps absorb moisture and toxins. While the "toxin removal" claims are marketing (your lymph nodes already do this), charcoal does effectively absorb sweat moisture.
Best For
- Budget-conscious shoppers new to natural deodorant
- Light to moderate sweaters with non-sensitive skin
- Trial period before committing to expensive brands
- Resilient skin that handles baking soda well
Not For
- Sensitive skin (30-40% irritation rate with baking soda)
- Heavy sweaters (won't last through intense activity)
- All-day protection without reapplication
The Bottom Line
Schmidt's is the best bang-for-buck natural deodorant—if your skin tolerates baking soda. Start here to test natural formulas before investing in premium options.




